Skip to main content
← Back to Library

How to Get Promoted: Why your track record isn't enough

Watch Video on YouTube
πŸ“„ The written version, with every source: https://keca.co.uk/articles/confidence-mistaken-for-potential Two managers up for the same promotion. The one with the stronger record is passed over, and nobody in the room thinks it was unfair. Organisational psychologist Dr Nick Keca on why a judgement of potential is a forecast of a job nobody has done yet, why it gets made from what the judges can see, and why what they see best, confidence, predicts who gets picked better than it predicts who leads well. In this episode: what the nine-box grid's potential rating is supposed to measure; the preference for promise over proof; overconfidence, and why it isn't penalised when it's exposed; the babble hypothesis, dominance and speaking time; extraversion and assertiveness; the Peter Principle, now with data; narcissism, psychopathy and the Dark Triad in who gets picked; the picture of a leader in the judge's head; the gap in self-promotion; and the field study in which the people rated lower on potential went on to outperform. The final third is practical: what predicts leading well, from humility to self-discipline; what to do if you're being judged, if you do the judging, and if you run the organisation; and what this research cannot tell you about any one colleague. Chapters 0:00 Talent review: who gets promoted 1:23 Why the stronger record lost 2:31 The nine-box matrix explained 4:40 Overconfidence vs competence 6:34 Three cautions on confidence 8:04 The babble hypothesis 9:39 The Peter Principle in data 11:08 The Dark Triad and promotion 12:47 Who gets rated high potential 14:30 What predicts good leadership 16:17 If you're judged on potential 17:45 Judging potential fairly 19:09 Better succession planning 20:43 The limits of this research 21:44 The full article and sources Educational content. Not psychological, legal or employment advice. Nothing in this video diagnoses anybody or describes any real person or organisation. The case that runs through the video is a composite.
/ Official Transcript

Full Video Text

Two managers were up for the same promotion. The one with the stronger record was passed over. Nobody in the room thought they'd been unfair. Here's the uncomfortable truth. When we judge someone's potential, we're judging how they'll do in a job they haven't done yet. So we judge what we can see instead.

And one of the things we see best is how sure somebody sounds. In this episode, I'll show you what a judgement of potential is really made from. Which personality traits it favours on both sides of the table. What actually predicts who'll do well. And what you can do about it, whether you're being judged or doing the judging.

Every autumn, the directors of a distribution business discuss their people around a grid of nine boxes. Performance along the bottom axis. Potential up the vertical axis. The first manager ran the busiest depot. He answered every question before it was finished. And told the directors what he'd do with the region before anyone asked him.

The second manager ran a smaller site. With the best safety record and the lowest staff turnover in the business. Asked if he was ready. He said he would be in a year or so. There were two things he said. He wanted to learn first. What By the end of the afternoon, the first manager was in the top right box, the second was in a box to the left.

The first manager got the region. Eighty months later, its figures were about where they'd started. The second manager's sight was still the best on safety. He'd stopped mentioning the two things he wanted to learn. The obvious question is whether the directors were biased, or whether the second manager should have pushed himself forward.

Continue reading transcript (46 more paragraphs)

The more useful question is this. When people judge something that hasn't happened yet, what do they look at instead? And whose personality does that favour? His story is a composite, drawn from practice and research. I'm Nick Kecker. I've spent more than 25 years in and around the boardrooms of all sorts of companies, large and small.

This episode shares what the research says and my own experience with corporate high potential talent programmes. Passions to Let's start by asking what potential is in the context of talent development. That grid, called the 9-box matrix or 3x3 matrix, is used by many large organisations. Performance describes a year that's already happened.

Potential is a forecast of future capability, typically how someone will do in a bigger job they've never held. It's a kind of bet. The trouble is, nobody agrees what potential measures. One major review of practice found that organisations and researchers disagree on what potential means and what it comprises.

It argued the first question should always be potential for what. The potential to run a region and the potential to lead a specialist team aren't the same thing at all. What organisations write down is revealing. When researchers built a model of leadership potential and tested it with 179 managers, one of the things inside it was self-promotion.

How well you put yourself forward was part of the definition. And people prefer promise over proof. In one experiment, 84 people read about an applicant for a leadership role at a bank. One version had two years relevant experience and a high score on a test of leadership achievement. The other had no relevant experience and the same score on a test of leadership potential.

People predicted the second would be more successful. Let's look at what that leaves the judge. On one side, a record. On the other, a job that hasn't happened. There's no direct evidence about the future because it hasn't happened. So the person making the call fills the information gap with what's available.

Who sounds sure? Who speaks first and most? Who looks the part? And who's best at the job below? Those four cues are what this episode is about. The question is the same for each one. What does it actually predict? What does Starting with the first, sounding sure. Psychologists use the word overconfidence for believing you're better than you are.

A subset of this is called the Dunning-Kruger effect. In one set of studies, 243 MBA students in 48 project teams were followed for 7 weeks. Those who claimed to know more than they did were rated by the teammates as more influential, even after allowing for how accurate they actually were. How did they claim to know more?

By saying they recognised terms that don't exist. In filmed group work, the overconfident individuals spoke more, offered more answers and used a more confident tone. The genuinely competent didn't do those things any more than anyone else and the overconfident weren't necessarily faking it. The study authors treat overconfidence as a belief people genuinely hold about themselves.

Now the obvious issue. Surely overconfidence gets found out. A follow-up study tested exactly that. Groups were shown how each individual had really performed. Surprisingly, the overconfident kept their standing. Then the step to potential itself was tested. In an experiment that varied confidence and competence separately, confidence elevated judgements of leadership potential at every level of competence tested.

In my experience, stepping up and telling the room what you do with a job before anyone asks is the behaviour most often quoted back in a talent review as evidence of potential. That's judgement from practice. Our second manager gave the more honest forecast of his readiness. It was heard as doubt. Thank Three cautions to position this research properly before we go on.

First, confidence and competence aren't opposites. Plenty of confident people are confident because they're good at their job. What the evidence says is that confidence is credited whether or not the competence is there. Marking someone down for sounding sure is the same mistake in reverse. The test is the record, not the manner.

Second, much of this evidence comes from students and online panels judging strangers. Real talent reviews are made by senior managers about people they tend to know. Nobody's measured the size of the confidence effect in that setting directly and the preference for promise came mostly from people described on paper.

The researchers suspect, without having tested it, that potential wouldn't outweigh a poor record in the real world. Third, this episode doesn't claim that judges are prejudiced and it isn't a way to spot narcissists across a meeting table. The directors in our story did what most talent managers do with the information they have.

Nothing in this episode tells you whether a particular colleague has potential. So this is about the cues and about what each cue does and doesn't predict. Where I'm offering judgement from practice rather than evidence, I'll say so. Good job. Thank you. Thank Next, the person who speaks first and most In a study of 68 students working in teams the team members higher in dominance meaning the habit of taking charge tended to gain more influence They were rated more competent even after allowing for their actual ability On one task, the team members who offered more answers were seen as leaders whether the answers were right made little difference A later study asked an obvious question Maybe people who talk more are just cleverer In small groups playing a long strategy game speaking time predicted who was nominated as leader after intelligence, personality and gender were accounted for People call it the babble hypothesis half as a joke Then there's extroversion Personality research describes people on five broad traits the big five and extroversion is the trait related to sociability energy and assertiveness A 2026 review of 203 datasets found that extroversion was linked with being picked as a leader mostly through one trait facet assertiveness And in a study of 79 groups extroverted individuals were picked as leaders more than they were rated effective That doesn't mean that extroverts make poor leaders It means extroversion buys more in the selection process than it tends to deliver in the actual job Then the person who's best at the job.

Since the 1960s, there's been a name for promoting people until they reach a job level they can't do well. The Peter Principle. For most of that time, it was a joke about bureaucracy. It now has data. Researchers followed salespeople in 131 firms, with each person's sales performance before promotion and the team's sales performance after it.

The best salespeople were the most likely to be promoted. They weren't the best managers. The study's authors estimate that choosing purely for management would have produced managers about 30% better at raising their team's sales performance. And here's the part that gets missed. A record of collaboration, selling jointly with colleagues, predicted how well a new managers team did.

It wasn't consistently related to who got promoted. Two cautions. The authors leave open whether the firms were simply wrong or used promotion as a reward to keep the best sellers selling. And sales are usually easy to count, so the effect may be weaker where the performance isn't. In my experience, a business region runs through lots of other people, so the second manager's steadier site and lower turnover were a far better guide.

That's knowledge from practice. That's knowledge from Much of this channel's content is about dark personality at work, and this is where it comes in. The darker traits help people get selected more than they help people lead effectively. Dark traits are usually referred to as the dark triad. Narcissism, meaning grandiosity and entitlement.

Machiavellianism, a cold willingness to manipulate. And psychopathy, reflecting low empathy with impulsiveness and boldness. A large synthesis of research data found that narcissism predicted who was picked as a leader, but not who was effective as a leader. Leaders high in narcissism rated themselves as more effective.

The people who worked with them didn't. And the link with being picked roughly halved once raters had known the person for more than a week. Psychopathy shows the same shape, but smaller. Across 92 samples, psychopathy showed a small advantage in being picked, and a small disadvantage in being effective.

Time matters too. In groups of strangers, meeting again and again, people who rated themselves above how others rated them, made a good impression at the first meeting, and a poor one by the seventh. None of this helps you spot a narcissist in a talent review. Most confident people aren't necessarily high in narcissism.

The point is that the talent process, which rewards how people come across on short acquaintance, will reward these traits more than they deserve. of an Lastly, who claims potential and who gets credit for it? First, the picture in the judge's head. Across 70 studies, the picture of a leader was closer to the picture of a man than of a woman.

It's weakened over time and it was stronger among men. And the same confidence isn't received equally. In one technology company, high-performing men gained influence by appearing self-confident. High-performing women gained it only when it came with visible concern for others. Then, how people described themselves.

In studies with more than 4,000 people online, women asked whether they'd done well on a maths and science test answered about 13 points lower, out of 100, than men who'd scored the same. The gap was just as big when it didn't matter. Where employers saw those answers, women were less likely to be hired and were paid less.

Here's the most striking evidence in this episode. In one retail chain, 29,809 management track staff were rated on performance and potential. Women got higher performance ratings and lower potential ratings. That difference accounted for about half the gap in promotion rates. And then the women went on to outperform the men.

So those potential ratings weren't accurate forecasts. The study authors put it down to stereotyping and to what they call strategic retention. Women were less likely to leave when passed over. That's a finding about the judges, not about anyone's ability. The If confidence isn't the evidence, what is?

Here's each move and what it rests on. Start with what predicts great leadership, because it's less obvious than what gets people picked. In that 2026 review, altruism, self-discipline and orderliness were among the better predictors of leading well, and had no link, or a negative one, with being picked.

Some of those results rest on few studies, or mostly on student leaders. Optimism were among the strongest predictors of leading well, more so for senior leaders. That's an expectation that things will turn out well, which isn't the same as overrating yourself. That distinction comes from how the two are measured, not from a study comparing them.

In the study of 79 groups, agreeable individuals were seen as trustworthy, and emotionally stable members as calm. Both mattered more for being effective than for being selected. And humility, rated by colleagues rather than by the person, predicted performance across eight samples. Humble leaders were associated with staff who were more engaged and more likely to stay.

Steadiness, trust, collaboration, humility. None of them is loud, and all of them take longer to notice. Our second manager wanted to learn more about two things. Budgeting across several sites, and managing managers. In my experience, naming exactly what you don't yet know is a clear sign of humility.

But talent reviews often record it as a lack of readiness. That's knowledge from practice. Thank you. If you're the one being judged, make the record speak before you do. Confidence is credited, whether or not it's backed, so a modest candidate's defence is a record that can't be talked over. Concrete, dated results, including results achieved through other people.

Put it in writing, before the meeting, not in it. That's judgement from practice. Then describe your readiness in evidence, not feeling. The gap in self-rating showed up even when nothing depended on it, which suggests modesty is often a habit, not a strategy. Replace, I think I'll be ready in a year, with what you've already done that the bigger job needs, and then what you'd learn in it.

That's not inflation, it turns a forecast about yourself into a record they can check. Get seen by people who've watched you work. The advantage of confident self-presentation fades as people get to know someone. Make sure some of them are heard. That fading is evidenced, the advice is practised. Take note of what the room rewards.

If potential's judged in a meeting, the meeting rewards whoever speaks first, and most. Prepare one short, specific point, make it early, and let the record do the rest. You don't have to become an extrovert to do that. Thank If you're assessing potential talent, all of this applies to you. That includes me.

Separate the forecast from the feeling. Before you rate anyone's potential, write down what it's a forecast of, which role and over what time frame. If the honest answer is that you were impressed, write that down and look for something else. Discount certainty, not the person. When a candidate's certain, ask what the certainty rests on.

When they're modest, ask the same question. Weigh the evidence behind a claim, not the force of it. Ask who else has seen them work. Judges who've known someone longer are less swayed by self-promotion. So before a review, get the view of at least one person who's worked for the candidate and one who's worked beside them, and give it equal weight as a presentation.

Then ask yourself three uncomfortable questions. Am I rating their likely effect on a team or their effect on me in the room? If they were modest, did I check the modesty against the record? And would I rate them the same if they did the job differently than I did? That's judgement from practice. None of the three has been studied directly and confirmed.

None of If you run the organisation, you can't train confidence out of your talent manager's perceptions, but you can stop a judgement made on a short-term acquaintance from deciding somebody's longer-term career. Audit the ratings themselves. Potential ratings in that retail chain were wrong in a predictable direction, so check whether the people you rate high go on to outperform those you rate lower by group.

Firms promoted on current performance when better predictors were there to see, so judge potential on what predicts the next job, not on what describes this one. And one model of potential listed self-promotion as a criterion. You'll have to stop listing it before you can stop rewarding it. From practice, four design choices.

Define potential for a specific role. Hear from people who've worked for and beside each candidate. Keep the rating out of the meeting where candidates are present, and track what the ratings go on to predict. And watch the moments when the cues are strongest and the evidence thinnest. A new leadership team, an outside shortlist, and a review by people who haven't watched a candidate's work.

Calibration meetings are widely used for this. Whether they make potential ratings more accurate, or just move them toward whoever talked most in the meeting remains unclear, and I couldn't find evidence to support either. No, it's not a review by people who Now what this research can't do. It can't tell you whether a particular colleague has potential, or whether you do.

These are patterns across large data sets of talent managers and candidates. The confident colleague may also be very good. The quiet one may genuinely not be ready. What does it give you is one question to ask of any assessment of potential, including your own. What was it made from? How sure did this sound?

How much did they speak? Did they look the part? How good they were at the job? And the uncomfortable part. Asked to forecast something that hasn't happened. Talent managers looked at what they can see, and what they see best predicts selection, better than it predicts great leadership. In the next episode, the trait behind the loudest voice in the room, extroversion, and what it really buys you.

What does the surprise whatΠΈΡ€ The written version of this episode is on my website with every citation and limitation and the five things I still don't know The link is included in the description below and is on the screen now If you found this episode useful please like and subscribe to my channel Each episode highlights a pattern of behaviour people get wrong at work Beyond helping the algorithm push my content to a larger audience subscribing is how you'll hear about the next episode And in the comments tell me Have you ever been judged on your potential or judged somebody else's?

What was it really like for you? I'm Nick Kecker Thanks for watching and thanks to everyone who's already subscribed I'll see you next time but in the meantime observe and act differently Thank