Skip to main content
← Back to Library

Dominance vs. Prestige: Which One Actually Wins Promotions?

Watch Video on YouTube
📄 The written version, with every source and every limit: https://keca.co.uk/articles/loudest-person-promoted A meeting's going nowhere, one person says firmly what to do, and six months later they're running the team. Sometimes that's right. Sometimes it's the start of a slow problem they're the last to see. Organisational psychologist Dr Nick Keca on extraversion's most forceful part, assertiveness: why rooms reward it, where it stops paying, and why about half the people who get it wrong can't hear it. In this episode: what assertiveness is, and how it sits inside extraversion; dominance and prestige, the two routes to influence; why dominant people are rated more competent than their ability supports; voice pitch and leadership; why anxious groups want a dominant leader; who is allowed to be loud, and how women and men are judged differently for taking the floor; the assertiveness curve, on which too much and too little both cost; why dominance fades over time; what dominance-driven leaders do when they feel threatened; and what extraversion really buys at work. The final third is practical: the line-crossing illusion and why so many people misjudge their own assertiveness; what to do if you're the quiet one, if you're the forceful one, and if you run the meeting or make promotion decisions; and what this research cannot tell you about any one colleague. Chapters 0:00 Who gets heard in meetings 1:37 The loud colleague who won 2:28 Dominance vs prestige 5:00 Why loud sounds competent 6:48 Three cautions on the research 7:43 Anxiety and dominant leaders 9:02 Women, talk time and backlash 10:33 Too assertive or not enough? 12:13 Why dominance fades over time 13:48 What extraversion really buys 15:48 Speaking up when you're quiet 17:11 If you're too forceful at work 18:15 How to run a fairer meeting 19:43 Limits of the research 20:34 Full article and sources Educational content. Not psychological, legal or employment advice. Nothing in this video diagnoses anybody or describes any real person or organisation. The case that runs through the video is a composite.
/ Official Transcript

Full Video Text

You've watched this happen. A meeting's going nowhere. Someone says firmly, here's what we do. The room relaxes. Six months on, they're running the entire team. Sometimes that's right, sometimes it's the start of a slow problem and the person concerned is the last to know. What you're watching is extraversion at work.

We all know an extravert when we see one, but what catches attention in management meetings is one particular facet of extraversion, assertiveness. In a group setting, it determines who gets heard and often who gets promoted. By the end of this episode, you'll know how to tell if a room was persuaded or just deferring, where a forceful voice stops paying off.

Why about half the people seen as too forceful or too quiet don't know it? And what to do about it, whether you're the quiet one, the forceful one or the person running the meeting. A steering committee had been meeting for four months. The project was late and nobody would name the problem. Then a programme manager spoke up firmly, the integration supplies the problem, give them 30 days or replace them.

Within 10 minutes, the meeting was discussing her 30 days. Near the end, an analyst who'd spent a month in the data said quietly that the delays came from a mismatch between two suppliers. The meeting chair said they'd take it offline. Nobody did. Six months later, the programme manager was promoted to lead the next phase.

But she was only partly right that supplier did have problems. The mismatch the analyst spotted and called out took five more months to surface. A year on, two of her best people had asked to move to another team. Her peers said she was hard to disagree with. She thought she'd been holding back. This story is a composite drawn from practice.

Continue reading transcript (43 more paragraphs)

I'm Nick Kecker. I've spent more than 25 years in and around the boardrooms, operations and change projects in all sorts of companies, large and small. This episode shares what the research says along with my own experience. The usual story is that the loudest person always gets promoted. The interesting questions are what the room actually heard when she spoke, why it stopped working, and why she was the last to know she had an issue.

Let's start with the trait itself. extraversion isn't one thing. It's a composite of a number of facets, including sociability, energy, good mood and assertiveness. Assertiveness is the loudest of those facets, the readiness to take charge, push a view and claim the floor. It's the colleague who tells the group what to do before anybody asked.

The lift is real. A 2019 synthesis of 97 earlier meta-analyses, studies that pull many other studies, found extraversion gave people a small, persistent advantage across most of their working life. A study that followed 457 people for about 14 years found that extraverts were the most likely to have advanced in their careers.

But there's a twist. People who were selfish, combative or manipulative were no more likely to have gained power than anyone else. The advantage is related to energy and drive, not to aggression. But being loud is two different things. Researchers who study status describe two routes to influence. Prestige is influence people give you because they admire what you know.

Dominance is influence you take because disagreeing with you comes with a cost. Here's what's unsettling. In groups working on a shared task, both routes worked. Dominance and prestige both moved the group's decision more. But only the prestigious were liked. Dominance had almost no link to being liked at all.

When other people watched the clips of these groups with an eye tracker, dominance drew their gaze, at least as strongly as prestige did. People looked at the forceful members and deferred to them. Let's look at what that means in a meeting. Two routes, one result. The room moves. From the outside you can't tell which route moved.

Often the person concerned can't tell either. That's the question this episode addresses. When a forceful voice carries the room, is the room persuaded or is it deferring? First, what the room hears. A forceful voice often sounds like competence, whether it is or not. Offering an answer, proposing a plan, speaking in the confident, settled tone all look like expertise.

You may remember the study from the last episode. In task groups, people hiring dominance were rated more competent by the teammates, by the observers and by the researchers, even after allowing for their actual ability. On a maths task, the people who emerged as leaders had offered the most answers, not necessarily the most correct ones.

That's the mechanism. They weren't winning by intimidation. They were sending signals the room couldn't tell apart from skill. Then there's the voice itself. In one set of experiments, the same sentence was recorded a little higher and a little lower, and listeners chose who they'd vote for. They chose the lower voice more often for men and for women.

About seven in ten heard a lower female voice as more competent and stronger. Remember that Elizabeth Holmes cultivated a lower speaking voice. In 792 male chief executives, those with lower voices run larger companies and earned more. That's an association, not proof that the voice caused it. Rank changes how people sound.

Students handed a high-ranking role before a negotiation changed their pitch and how much their loudness varied. Strangers could discern who held the rank from the recording alone. Nobody chose their voice and nobody listening knows they're responding to it. I want to position three cautions before we go on.

First, loud isn't the same as wrong. A forceful person can be genuinely skilled, and her 30-day suggestion did help. Judge what was said, not how it was said. Second, quiet isn't the same as deep. Some quiet colleagues have nothing to add on a subject. Treating silence as hidden wisdom is the same mistake in reverse.

Third, most of this research data comes from student studies and strangers working together for short periods, so it needs to be treated accordingly, with caution. This is about what the room hears, and what that does and doesn't predict. As we go on, where I'm offering my own judgement rather than evidence-based data, I'll say so.

When does a loud voice work best? When people feel out of control. A forceful leader offers borrowed control and anxious people want exactly that. In a series of studies, Americans living in areas with more economic uncertainty measured from unemployment, empty housing and poverty said they'd prefer a more dominant leader and a less prestigious one.

Across more than 138,000 people in 69 countries, rising unemployment predicted a stronger preference for a strong leader and part of that link ran through people feeling they'd lost control of their own lives. Those studies focused on political leaders so I infer it applies in the workplace but the mechanism isn't specific to politics.

Think about that steering group. Four months late, over budget, nobody willing to commit. That's exactly the situation where the 30-day stopgap delivered in a firm voice feels like relief. And relief is easy to mistake for good judgement. Her plan might have been right. The relief would have felt the same either way.

So the more lost a team feels, the more easily a forceful voice can pass for a plan. But the reward for taking the floor isn't the same for everybody, so we should ask who's permitted to be loud. In United States Senate debates, senators with more power spoke for longer if they were men. For women, no comparable link emerged.

An experiment suggests why. A female chief executive described as talking more than others was rated less competent and less fit to lead. A male chief executive who talked more was rated higher, and both men and women judged it the same way. Across 71 studies, women were penalised more than men for overt dominance, like direct commands or claiming the floor.

The costs relied mainly on how much they were liked, not on how competent they seemed. Subtle and non-verbal signals carried little or no penalty. And the rules of the meeting matter. In 94 discussion groups, women spoke less than their share under majority rule. When the group had to agree unanimously, the gap largely disappeared, especially for women who were outnumbered.

Same people, different rule. That's a finding about how talk is rewarded, not about anyone's ability. A quiet woman in your meeting may have learned accurately what speaking up would cost her. And the person running the meeting can influence that by building psychological safety. Now, the finding that should change how you think about all this.

Most people assume more is better. If being forceful works, more of it should work better. It doesn't. The effect is curvilinear. In one study, former co-workers described 168 MBA students' strengths and weaknesses. Assertiveness came up in just over half of all the weakness comments, more than any other theme, and the complaints split almost evenly.

48 % said too much, 52 % said too little. Think about how unusual that is. Intelligence, conscientiousness, charisma. People almost always complain that someone doesn't have enough. Assertiveness may be the one quality people complain about in both directions. Then 213 people rated the last manager they'd worked for.

The least and most assertive thirds were both rated less effective than the middle third, and for different reasons. The least assertive didn't get things done. The most assertive didn't get along with people. And the curve held after controlling for extraversion. That's our programme manager. The firmness that moved a stalled steering group became, once she ran a team, the thing her peers named when they were asked what was wrong.

But the quiet candida isn't safe by default either. Too little was just as common a complaint. So the middle wins, and the middle isn't the loudest point on the scale. That personality at work is a common theme on this channel and this is where it comes in Because dominance has two more limits and the second is darker The first is time In 66 student project groups followed for 16 weeks both dominance and prestige went with higher rank at the start But over the weeks only prestige went on raising someone's ranking Dominance is lasting effect was negligible Dominance buys influence early when a group knows little about its members It doesn't keep buying it as time passes.

It's an initial loan not a permanent gift The second is what happens when a dominance driven person is in charge and feels under threat Across five experiments people put in charge of a group were given chances to help it or hinder it Leaders high in the motive to dominate withheld useful information Excluded a highly skilled member and kept a capable member from influencing the task But only when their own position was unstable Leaders low in that motive didn't do it When the group was competing against another group that behaviour disappeared the interests of the leaders and the group realigned Now look at that from the analyst's point of view The most capable person on a team can threaten a leader who rose through the ranks based on dominance And the leader may never describe it to themselves that way So what does the extraversion trait really buy you?

That 2019 synthesis deconstructed extraversion into its individual trait facets. Feeling positive emotion had the broadest benefits at work, then dominance, assertiveness and energy. Sociability, the part most people picture, conferred few benefits. It also found extraversion was linked more strongly with being rated an effective leader than with being picked as one.

In the last episode, I said extraversion buys more in the job selection process than it delivers in the job. That rested mainly on one study of 79 groups. This larger synthesis points the other way, so I'd put it more carefully and with caution. Those effectiveness ratings come from people who may be hearing the same signals.

So, moderate assertiveness helps. What it doesn't reliably buy is the judgement of when to push. And here's the problem I promised at the start. Many of us can't judge our own level of assertiveness. In a study of negotiations, 56 % of people seen as too assertive thought they'd come across about right or even too soft. And 57 % of those seen as not assertive enough thought they're reverse.

It gets stranger. Researchers also found a line-crossing illusion. Many people who'd pitched it right believed they'd gone too far. And some made costly concessions to repair a relationship that wasn't damaged. An earlier review by the same researcher reports something similar at work. Around half the managers they staff saw as too assertive or not assertive enough were also seen as lacking awareness of it.

Our programme manager thought she'd been holding back. The evidence suggests she wasn't unusual. What do you do with this? It depends on where you sit. If you're the quiet one, you don't need to become loud. You need to move from your end of the curve towards the middle. Three moves and their judgement from practice built on the evidence.

In meetings, speak early, speak once and speak with a reason. Rooms reward people who offer answers and they're most open to solutions when they're anxious. One specific point made before somebody else sets the frame is usually worth more than several made late. Something like, before we decide, here's what the data show and why it's important.

Make the contribution visible. Admiration builds on what a group sees you contribute. So after the meeting, send the attendees a short written summary of your analysis. And check before you retreat. That feeling of having pushed too hard is an unreliable guide. Before you apologise or give ground, ask someone who was in the room whether any concerns need addressing.

Often nothing does. And don't try to be the loudest in the room. The curve says it doesn't help. Moving towards the middle is a much smaller change than becoming somebody else. If you're the forceful one, here's the hard part. Your own sense of how it went is the least reliable source you've got, so ask someone who was in the meeting.

But don't ask whether you were too much. That just invites reassurance. Ask what the quietest person in the room would have said if they'd spoken. In my experience, that question gets you a more honest answer. Bring the reason, not just the conclusion. Forceful people get read as competent because they offer more answers.

Saying why you think something gives the room more to judge than your delivery. That's how the room tells the difference between persuasion and pressure. And watch for the threat moment. When your own position feels shaky, perhaps due to a reorganisation or a new boss, notice who you're leaving out of the work that would make them visible.

The experiments show the pattern. Spotting it in yourself is a judgement and it's yours to make. If you chair the meeting, you have real influence over the outcomes. Often without noticing, you decide how much the room rewards the first forceful voice. Ask the quietest relevant person first, before the most senior or most forceful person has framed the question.

Ask everyone to share the view or write it down before discussion so the range of input is visible before anyone starts to dominate. Also ask for reasons, not just conclusions. Reasoning is much harder to perform than self-confidence. For decisions that matter, ask for consensus, not just the majority.

It takes longer, but that's the clearest evidence we have that a meeting's rules change who speaks. When the room is anxious, say so and ask what you'd decided if you'd felt calm. If you make promotion decisions, be wary of deciding early. A few months of visible energy is exactly when the fade hasn't had time to show.

Ask the people who've worked with a candidate the longest, not the ones who've seen them in most meetings, and ask about both ends of the curve. What happens when this person disagrees with the peer, and what happens when somebody disagrees with them? Not these have been tested as an intervention in an ordinary workplace, they're recent extensions of the research findings.

Now, what the research doesn't tell you, it can't tell you whether a particular colleague is dominant or whether you are. These are patterns across many people and many groups. The forceful colleague may be right, the quiet one may have nothing to add. What he does give you is a question to ask and a framework to think about the situation when a forceful voice carries the room.

Were people persuaded or did disagreeing feel too expensive? And one question you can ask yourself, where do you sit on the curve? You probably can't tell, so ask someone who knows you well. In the next episode, the idea you had in a meeting that somebody else gets the credit for and why they often sincerely believe it was theirs.

The written version of this episode is on my website, with every citation and limitation. The link is down below and on the screen now. If you found this useful and interesting, please like and subscribe to my channel. Each episode takes a pattern of behaviour people get wrong at work. Without your support, my content won't reach the other people that may be interested.

And tell me in the comments, have you ever watched The Loudest Voice win a meeting and wondered if you were right to worry, or been The Loud One and found out later? I'm Nick Kecker, thanks for watching and thanks to all those who've already subscribed. It's appreciated. I'll see you next time, but in the meantime, observe and act differently.